The same amount of energy can arrive as electricity or as heat supplied close to the temperature of the surroundings. These transfers offer different possibilities for obtaining work. Energy remains conserved during subsequent transformations, while its availability depends on the system and its surroundings. Heat supplied near ambient temperature offers little scope for producing work through a heat engine. Counting the energy alone leaves that difference invisible. Thermodynamics needs entropy alongside its energy account to describe the constraints on what can happen. 1
An economic comparison can also require more than one kind of information. A buyer willingly pays a price that covers the seller's costs, while production uses up a capacity shared with other people. Agreement about the purchase does not establish that the capacity has been maintained. We propose retaining market value and adding a complementary measure of natural and social capital. The purpose is to make preserving productive potential count in ordinary decisions about production and exchange. 2
The physical comparison raises a question about what economic measures should reveal. Different measures can be necessary because they answer different questions. People's preferences do not follow from a thermodynamic calculation, and scientific information cannot decide whose rights should prevail. It begins with a social commitment: a sustainable economy should maintain the natural and social capital supporting its activities. The complementary measure would express that commitment in a form people can use when comparing methods and contributions.
Market value remains useful because people want different things. Prices allow specialised producers to exchange outputs and consumers to choose among available arrangements. The second measure asks what productive potential an activity uses or restores. Two methods may satisfy the same demand while creating different maintaining obligations. Bringing those obligations into the calculation changes which methods are attractive. It leaves substantial freedom over how to produce, while making the continued availability of shared capacities part of the conditions of success.
The first principle concerns comparability. It treats natural resources, usable energy and organised information as forms of productive potential that can be expressed through a measure of natural and social capital. Their useful organisation is what I call negentropy. Once expressed in the proposed measure, losses and contributions are additive. An account can then combine changes along a production chain. This is an economic premise requiring operational conversion rules; it should not be mistaken for a physical proof that every kind of organisation is interchangeable.
Additivity matters because production is divided among many agents. A component passes through several activities before someone purchases the finished product. If each stage ignored what came before, the final account would omit much of the resource use. If every stage assumed responsibility for the entire history, the same loss would be charged repeatedly. A coherent account needs to carry information through the chain while identifying the contribution or obligation attributable to each activity. The common measure is intended to make that consolidation possible.
The preservation principle supplies the purpose of the account. Use and transformation can degrade productive potential. A sustainable arrangement would compensate for the relevant degradation through maintaining processes, keeping capital available. Renewable energy flows make some of this work possible without consuming an equivalent finite fuel stock. Capturing and using those flows still require equipment and resources. When I describe the arriving flow as free, I mean that its use need not deplete a fuel reserve; the machinery and effort needed to use it remain inside the calculation.
Maintenance can involve a different process from the one that formed the original resource. Recovering useful material need not mean collecting every original particle. The relevant test concerns an equivalent productive capacity under specified conditions. That flexibility is important for innovation, but it needs limits. A transfer of money does not prove that a replacement exists. Some losses, including unique genetic information destroyed through extinction, lie beyond the proposed compensable domain. Their protection requires constraints that an unrelated positive balance cannot satisfy.
The reference condition is dynamic. Over the timescale relevant to the account, we can assume that natural and social capital can be treated as maintaining an equilibrium in the absence of economic disturbance. This provides a baseline against which activity is assessed. Natural conditions and institutions can change for other reasons, so applying the premise requires identifying those changes. The account must state its boundary, its period and what it treats as the activity's effect. Otherwise an apparently precise total can hide uncertainty about what was measured.
These principles recast externalities around productive capital. A societal cost records the capacity used; a societal contribution records what an activity provides towards maintenance or useful additions. Contribution minus cost gives the activity's externality within the defined scope. A business can therefore earn a financial surplus while retaining an outstanding societal obligation. A specialised maintaining activity can make a positive contribution that is poorly represented when attention rests on the selling price of the original product.
Consider two producers offering equivalent output. One disperses material into a form requiring expensive collection and separation before reuse. The other keeps it accessible and reduces the work required for recovery. Customers may value their products equally. The complementary account would distinguish the maintaining obligations created by the methods. It would give both producers an incentive to improve the entire process, including its aftermath. A recovery business could compete to meet the remaining obligation with fewer resources, with its contribution supported by observations of the actual process.
A figure in this second account would need an explanation a producer can use. The firm should be able to trace the assessment to a resource quantity and an identified maintaining process. If another method meets the same responsibility more effectively, the rules should allow that information to change the comparison. In this way the measure could direct experimentation without requiring an authority to choose every production technique. Its discipline would come from a consistent obligation and evidence of the result.
The practical test is whether these comparisons can be made credibly. We need physical quantities behind the common measure so that changes in restoration methods can be examined and the accounts revised. We also need agreement about the capacities to preserve and institutions answerable for their decisions. The proposal gives preservation an economic role that continues after the initial transaction. It asks an activity to show what supports its earnings, what it consumes and how the maintaining responsibility has been met. Those questions can become part of routinely examined economic performance.
Equal energy supplied as electricity or near-ambient heat offers different possibilities for work, just as equal market values can conceal different demands on the productive potential an economy needs to maintain.
References
1. Urone, P. P., & Hinrichs, R. (2022). College physics 2e. OpenStax. https://openstax.org/books/college-physics-2e/pages/15-6-entropy-and-the-second-law-of-thermodynamics-disorder-and-the-unavailability-of-energy
2. Lascols, B. (2026). Capital and entropy: Theory of negentropic value (4th ed.). Accounting for externalities.
