Scatter dots across a page and connect a few neighbouring pairs. At first, the lines join small islands. Add enough connections and a large connected group can emerge, stretching across much of the page. Percolation theory studies transitions of this kind, including the conditions under which networks remain connected after failures. The change lies in the relationships among the dots; the individual dots can remain exactly where they were. 1 A business operates within relationships that are harder to draw, yet easily overlooked when attention settles on its own performance. Its premises may be privately owned; the conditions that make them productive extend well beyond the gate.
A new employee arrives with years of learning already completed. Contracts work because people share a language and recognise legal institutions. Goods travel through infrastructure supported by earlier investment. These contributions do not diminish the firm's own achievement. They help explain how it became possible. We use social capital to describe organised capabilities of this kind, and ask how an enterprise's use of them can be placed beside its contribution to maintaining them. Profit records a result within the firm; we also need an account of its relationship with the society around it. 2
Adam Smith already gave public institutions a place in a commercial society. He described works advantageous to society whose expense private investors could not expect to recover, and considered public support for education. He also worried that narrow, repetitive employment could damage workers' intellectual capacities. 3 We lose part of his economic argument when we retain specialisation and exchange while forgetting the institutions required to sustain the people doing the work. The question of who maintains these capabilities belongs inside economic reasoning.
Membership gives the account its first boundary. A company operating in a country uses arrangements maintained by that society and incurs obligations within it. A multinational participates in several such settings. Each has its own public services and rules. We must identify them before calculating a balance. An obligation to one community cannot simply become an obligation to every community everywhere, and a contribution recognised in one place cannot be counted repeatedly wherever the company happens to operate.
Taxation provides a familiar starting point. Schools need continuing resources, as do the institutions through which contracts are enforced. The benefit received by each firm cannot be isolated exactly. Tracing an engineer's every productive hour to particular lessons would be an expensive fiction. An agreed tax obligation supplies a workable reference for participation in the collective arrangement. It does not claim to measure the full benefit of each service to each taxpayer, or certify that all public expenditure is well chosen.
Trouble begins when the geography of recorded profit separates from the geography of activity. A firm can recruit educated workers and use infrastructure in one country while recording much of its profit elsewhere. The proposed account compares the tax paid with an obligation estimated by allocating profits using observable activity, such as employment or sales. A shortfall enters as a negative contribution to the community concerned. This is an allocation convention: the selected indicators and their weights must be visible, since different rules distribute the same profit differently. The accountant need not identify the classroom that would otherwise have been funded. The shortfall concerns participation in a pool. This allows us to recognise an obligation without inventing a detailed history of every consequence of an unpaid contribution. It also explains why a multinational's global tax total can be insufficient information. The question includes where the contribution was due and which organised capacity supported the activity producing its income.
Subsidies run in the other direction. Public resources enter a private organisation because a government expects a benefit. The recipient initially records a societal cost. A subsequent contribution can counterbalance it when that contribution becomes available. Suppose support pays for research whose usable findings are later released. The receipt and the release are separate events with separate dates. Recording the hoped-for benefit immediately would allow an expectation to cancel an actual withdrawal before anyone outside the firm had received anything.
Exclusive rights require particular care. By convention, the contribution associated with protected research is recognised when restrictions on its shared use end. Patent publication can disclose technical information earlier, while the right to prevent certain commercial uses continues. 4 These are different forms of access. The convention concerns the point at which the protected contribution enters a commonly usable stock; it should never imply that the information stayed secret throughout the patent's life. We must say which access an entry represents.
A donation presents another easily missed counterpart. Money given to a shared activity may bring a tax deduction. The gift contributes to one arrangement while the deduction reduces the payment to another. Both changes belong in the account. Without them, the same spending can acquire a generous reputation while part of its public financing remains concealed. Following these counterparts makes the balance less dependent on the story the contributor chooses to tell about the transaction.
Insurance offers a smaller cooperative setting. Members pay premiums into a pool that absorbs losses. In a simplified account, premiums are contributions and the costs borne by the pool are societal costs. Risky conduct or false declarations can increase what other members must pay. A claim, however, can result from sheer misfortune. The balance describes a relationship with the pool; it does not pronounce a moral judgement on someone whose house has burned down. Circumstances still matter when rules and premiums are set.
Widening the boundary changes the account. A transfer between two members becomes internal when their whole group is considered. The state's consolidated budget therefore raises a different question from an enterprise's contribution to public provision. This says nothing about the fairness of that budget. Humanity as a whole has no external human group with which to settle a social balance, although its dependencies on the natural environment remain. A boundary specifies the relationship being measured; it does not make every other relationship disappear.
What should change for a firm reading such accounts? It should be able to distinguish an improvement in its own performance from an advantage financed by neglected collective obligations. It should also receive recognition when it returns usable capabilities to others. Reliable entries will require conventions and evidence, and obtaining that evidence has a cost. Yet the underlying question is ordinary enough: when a successful activity draws on a shared inheritance, what does it help keep available for those who follow?
As scattered dots become connected through their links, private enterprise becomes productive through shared arrangements whose upkeep belongs beside its own achievements.
References
1. Mohseni-Kabir, A., Pant, M., Towsley, D., Guha, S., & Swami, A. (2021). Percolation thresholds for robust network connectivity. Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment, 2021(1), Article 013212. https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-5468/abd312
2. Lascols, B. (2026). Capital and entropy: Theory of negentropic value (4th ed.). Accounting for externalities.
3. Smith, A. (1904). An inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations (E. Cannan, Ed.). Methuen & Co. https://www.econlib.org/library/Smith/smWN.html (Original work published 1776)
4. World Intellectual Property Organization. (n.d.). Frequently asked questions: Patents. https://www.wipo.int/en/web/patents/faq_patents
