A molecular structure on a computer screen looks like a finished object: a folded ribbon, coloured by its parts, ready to rotate. Behind it sits a continuing human effort. Researchers collect evidence. Depositors describe their results. Biocurators examine the structure and its supporting information before it enters the Protein Data Bank. Shared conventions allow other researchers to retrieve and compare it. Open access enables reuse, while maintenance helps keep the record intelligible. 1 The archive makes knowledge visible as something people organise and entrust to one another, long after the experiment producing an individual entry has ended.
An idea can be used without being used up. That familiar observation can make knowledge sound maintenance free. Yet a file can survive after the skills needed to interpret it have disappeared. A useful discovery can remain difficult to apply because access is restricted. An unreliable explanation can consume the time of everyone trying to build upon it. The principal concern is the usable capability that reaches another person. Keeping this capability available is part of maintaining social capital, and should affect how we recognise contributions to it. 2
Kenneth Arrow explained why information fits awkwardly into ordinary exchange. A potential buyer may need to learn what information contains before knowing its value; once it has been revealed, part of the reason to buy it has gone. Reproduction can also be cheap, making the returns difficult for its producer to capture. Legal protection helps create an incentive to invent while limiting some subsequent uses. 3 The tension runs through research policy: financing the work and spreading its benefits involve different economic requirements.
I approach the accounting question through the effort that builds a shared capability. A discovery's eventual applications may emerge decades later, through people its originators never meet. Some will disappoint; others may prove valuable in unexpected settings. Trying to price every future consequence would leave the account waiting for a story that never finishes. We can instead record the resources devoted to research and ask when the resulting work becomes available beyond the organisation that financed it.
Research is cumulative. A celebrated result may depend on years of instrument development and investigations that attracted little attention. Recognising only conspicuous successes would erase much of the work that made them possible. Costs, including researchers' work, provide a starting basis for recording this investment. They are historical evidence of resources committed, rather than a forecast of all future earnings. The account must retain that distinction whenever a striking commercial application tempts us to rewrite the value of everything that preceded it.
Spending alone cannot guarantee a contribution. A project can consume a large budget and leave an unusable record. Publication allows other people to examine a claim, but does not establish its accuracy. We therefore need evidence of what has become available and conventions for recognising it.
Careful documentation matters because another researcher must be able to understand what was done. Verification matters because unsupported results can send subsequent work in the wrong direction. These activities maintain the quality of the inherited resource.
Education makes the same dependency familiar. The ability of a newly hired employee did not begin with the employment contract. Families and teachers helped develop it over many years, often through publicly supported institutions. An employer benefits when someone arrives able to interpret a drawing or solve a technical problem. Taxation supports part of this continuing provision. The wage pays for work under the current contract; it does not describe the entire history through which the worker acquired the ability to perform it.
Employers add to this inheritance too. Compare a course on an internal procedure with training that teaches a recognised skill. Both can help the business. The second may also enlarge the capabilities available to other employers and the wider society. Transferability is decisive. Calling an expense training does not establish a social contribution if the learning has no use beyond the firm's own arrangements. The account asks what the employee can carry into another setting.
That ability must be accompanied by freedom to move. A worker may acquire transferable skills while remaining subject to conditions that temporarily prevent their use elsewhere. We can delay recognition of the shared contribution until those restrictions end. This convention connects the availability of knowledge with the position of its human carrier. People retain their own purposes; they are free to decide where their abilities will be used. We should not credit an employer with a fully shared resource while it controls the only permitted use.
Patents create a related distinction between disclosure and unrestricted use. Publication can make an invention's technical information public while exclusive rights still constrain its commercial exploitation. 4 The accounting convention recognises the protected contribution when the relevant restrictions end. It follows an emphasis on shared use, without denying that readers could study the disclosure beforehand. The convention also leaves room to debate whether particular protection arrangements encourage enough useful research to justify their restrictions. An accounting date cannot settle that policy question by itself.
Public support makes the sequence particularly clear. A firm receiving a research subsidy draws on a collective resource. If it subsequently releases usable findings, it returns a contribution. Exclusive protection can separate these events by years. Keeping their dates distinct prevents an expected benefit from cancelling a cost before the benefit exists. The geographical boundary also matters: one country may finance research whose published results can be used around the world. A credible account must identify both the funding relationship and the community receiving access.
There is a less celebrated form of depletion: an accumulation of misleading material. A repository can grow in size while becoming harder to use. Readers then spend more effort separating dependable evidence from assertions, and errors travel into subsequent decisions. Teaching and critical review help prevent that deterioration. Their contribution may be easy to overlook because it seldom appears as a spectacular discovery, yet it protects the ability to make sense of discoveries at all. A society supporting research needs to support this patient work as well.
The practical test is whether someone else can inherit something usable and continue the work. A financial total provides evidence of spending; a shared capability gives that spending its purpose. A specific accounting can makes this connection visible enough to influence choices about training and research. It should encourage organisations to leave understandable results and transferable abilities behind them, while avoiding an automatic reward for whatever can be presented as a large research bill.
The Protein Data Bank's shared molecular structures remain productive because people can retrieve and interpret them, just as knowledge becomes lasting economic capital through the access and care that let others continue its use.
References
1. Burley, S. K., Berman, H. M., Bhikadiya, C., Bi, C., Chen, L., Di Costanzo, L., Christie, C., Dalenberg, K., Duarte, J. M., Dutta, S., Feng, Z., Ghosh, S., Goodsell, D. S., Green, R. K., Guranović, V., Guzenko, D., Hudson, B. P., Kalro, T., Liang, Y., … Zardecki, C. (2019). RCSB Protein Data Bank: Biological macromolecular structures enabling research and education in fundamental biology, biomedicine, biotechnology and energy. Nucleic Acids Research, 47(D1), D464–D474. https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gky1004
2. Lascols, B. (2026). Capital and entropy: Theory of negentropic value (4th ed.). Accounting for externalities.
3. Arrow, K. J. (1962). Economic welfare and the allocation of resources for invention. In The rate and direction of inventive activity: Economic and social factors (pp. 609–626). Princeton University Press. https://www.nber.org/system/files/chapters/c2144/c2144.pdf
4. World Intellectual Property Organization. (n.d.). Frequently asked questions: Patents. https://www.wipo.int/en/web/patents/faq_patents
