A suit of armour can become a burden in a different environment. Researchers introduced marine sticklebacks carrying different armour variants into freshwater ponds. Over a generation, the variant associated with fewer bony plates increased in frequency after the plates developed, probably through a growth advantage. Selection had acted differently at an earlier life stage. The experiment made adaptation visible as a relationship between inherited characteristics and particular conditions. Past success offered no guarantee that a characteristic would remain advantageous everywhere, or even throughout the animal's life. 1
Economic success also depends on its setting. A production method can enrich a society while making growing demands on resources that its accounts scarcely recognise. We can read economic evolution through changes in those dependencies. People overcome a constraint, acquire new capabilities and build ways of living around them. The resulting success can obscure what the arrangement still needs. When conditions change, the machinery of prosperity may continue rewarding methods that consume its foundations. 2
Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen described the importance of exosomatic development: tools and productive equipment extend human capabilities outside the body. Such capacities can accumulate and pass between generations through knowledge and artefacts. Economic change therefore has a channel that differs from biological inheritance. People can improve a method, teach it and organise access to its equipment within their own lifetimes. The capabilities inherited by a community include much more than the physical characteristics of its members. 3
Cooperation makes this inheritance useful. A tool without someone able to operate it is an incomplete resource. A technique disappears if nobody retains or transmits it. As capabilities grow, so does dependence on the relationships that keep them accessible. We can understand economic history partly through this accumulation of natural and social capital, without forcing every society onto an identical sequence. Earlier arrangements were also capable of exhausting soils or forests; closeness to nature never guaranteed prudent use.
Agriculture altered the management of dependence. Cultivation and animal husbandry gave people greater influence over supplies, while storage separated some consumption from the moment of production. The dependence continued through seasons, soils and the conditions of biological growth. Producing more food could support further specialisation, including the development of better tools and knowledge. Success amplified the capabilities through which it had been obtained. Yet no storehouse could manufacture another growing season whenever its contents ran low.
Fossil energy transformed the scale and timing of that opportunity. Machinery could accomplish work far beyond human muscle. A stock accumulated over geological time became available within an investment horizon. Mining and transport expanded; goods could be made on different terms. These were substantial gains in capability and comfort. Their apparent abundance encouraged an economy to treat inherited resources as cheap inputs, while measuring success more carefully at the point of sale than at the point where those resources were depleted.
The price of extraction pays for access, equipment and labour under the prevailing rules. It does not necessarily provide for maintaining the productive potential consumed or dealing with residues after use. Industrial expansion can therefore relax one constraint while intensifying another. A business sees affordable power; the shared environment receives additional material flows. The advantage is particularly strong when the cost omitted from one enterprise is spread among people unable to influence its immediate decisions.
William Stanley Jevons saw why technical progress alone might accelerate this process. In The Coal Question, he argued that more efficient engines could make coal-powered production cheaper, attract investment and enlarge its uses. Saving fuel per unit was compatible with consuming more fuel overall. The argument identifies a mechanism, rather than a universal prediction that every efficiency improvement must raise total consumption. Output responds to demand, prices and other constraints. A better engine changes the opportunities available within that setting. 4
That distinction matters for innovation. An engineer can succeed brilliantly at an assigned task while the industry moves further from maintaining its supporting resources. If the task is to produce a cheaper disposable component, ingenuity will follow that instruction. Suppliers and customers may then adapt to frequent replacement. A durable alternative has to find a place within an arrangement built for another outcome. Technical quality alone cannot determine which method prospers; the surrounding incentives help decide which advantages become commercially useful.
I propose changing those incentives by making the maintenance of natural and social capital a condition of economic success. An activity using shared productive potential would carry an obligation corresponding to its maintenance. A design that saves resources across repeated use could then gain from that saving. A method whose low price depended on leaving costly residues behind would lose part of its advantage. Competition would continue, with a different basis for deciding what constitutes a successful improvement.
The change would reach the direction of research as well as the choice between existing machines. A persistent maintenance charge gives a firm a reason to investigate a neglected recovery method. A recognised contribution can support work whose benefit previously appeared elsewhere. The new constraint helps form the opportunities among which enterprise and investment will choose.
This is selection through institutions and human choices, with none of the moral authority sometimes borrowed from biological competition. A profitable business is not thereby entitled to survive, and an unprofitable one does not make its employees less worthy. People can revise the rules and support those whose livelihoods depend on a declining arrangement. Our capacity for foresight makes a deliberate transition possible. It also makes us responsible for the distribution of its burdens, including burdens that a resource calculation alone cannot settle.
Timing is part of the mechanism. Equipment lasts for years, skills are specialised and whole communities depend on established supply chains. A credible obligation announced early enough can influence the next investment. An abrupt rule applied after alternatives have disappeared offers a much harsher education. We need time to discover workable methods and develop the capacities they require, while checking that an apparent improvement has not merely moved its demands beyond the new account's boundary.
The historical question then becomes a question about purpose. Greater control over food and mechanical work expanded human possibilities. We can now direct some of that accumulated capability towards maintaining what makes those possibilities durable. The objective is a resource relationship that remains workable through time. Output still matters, yet a rising output figure cannot establish whether we have improved the productive inheritance available to those who follow us or simply become more efficient at spending it.
Freshwater altered the advantage of stickleback armour, while foresight allows us to change the economic conditions rewarding a production method before depletion leaves adaptation with fewer choices.
References
1. Barrett, R. D. H., Rogers, S. M., & Schluter, D. (2008). Natural selection on a major armor gene in threespine stickleback. Science, 322(5899), 255–257. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1159978
2. Lascols, B. (2026). Capital and entropy: Theory of negentropic value (4th ed.). Accounting for externalities.
3. Georgescu-Roegen, N. (1971). The entropy law and the economic process. Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.4159/harvard.9780674281653
4. Jevons, W. S. (1866). The coal question: An inquiry concerning the progress of the nation, and the probable exhaustion of our coal-mines (2nd ed.). Macmillan and Co. https://www.econlib.org/library/YPDBooks/Jevons/jvnCQ.html (Original work published 1865)
