Accounting for Externalities > English > What Negentropic Money Would Pay For

Put several measurements into a table and ask which observations are closest. The answer depends on the ruler. A difference of ten means something different in centimetres and metres. Two measurements that usually move together can also repeat much of the same information. In 1936, Prasanta Chandra Mahalanobis described a statistical distance that accounts for variation and correlations among measurements. A difference is assessed against the structure of the data, changing what counts as near. 1

This kind of metric later became a working tool in machine learning. In 2009, Kilian Weinberger and Lawrence Saul showed how to learn a Mahalanobis metric from labelled examples for nearest-neighbour classification. Their method sought to bring examples from the same class close together while separating other classes. 2 The connection is specific: changing how distance is measured supports a different way to classify observations. A metric becomes useful through the decisions and tools built around it. The economic question is what we could do once shared resource obligations had a workable measure.

I call one such tool negentropic money, or societal currency. Its purpose is to make the maintenance of natural and social capital enter economic decisions. We begin with an account: societal contribution minus societal cost equals externality. A negative balance means that the activity's recognised contribution falls short of the effort needed to maintain the shared capital it uses. The monetary instrument gives that shortfall a consequence through a requirement to buy tradable rights. 3

A company may understand a restoration requirement and still choose the method producing it because the ordinary price remains attractive. Purchasing rights changes the comparison. Reducing the negative balance lowers the requirement to obtain them. Maintaining shared capital becomes relevant when equipment is selected and processes are designed. This is the role of the instrument: it carries information from the societal account into the costs facing the decision maker. Measuring an obligation and giving someone a reason to reduce it are successive tasks.

Consider two ways to supply a metal component. One disperses valuable material after use; the other makes collection and separation easier. The second may cost more to manufacture while leaving a smaller restoration requirement. A rights purchase makes that difference financially relevant before the component is made. The comparison must include the recovery process's own energy and material demands, since easier collection cannot excuse an unrecorded withdrawal elsewhere. A producer can then compare the additional manufacturing cost with the reduced obligation, using evidence about both routes. The instrument gives the wider account a place in an ordinary investment decision.

Positive contributions supply the other side of the market. Activities with a recognised surplus can issue rights and sell them. Work that adds to common capital can consequently earn income. The amount follows the balance under the agreed conventions. A pleasant label or good intention supplies no equivalent evidence. We need to establish what became available, when it became available and whether another claim has already been made for the same contribution. The unit's credibility depends on the account supporting its issue.

The economy cannot be assumed to achieve balance immediately. Existing production methods leave substantial requirements that an abrupt obligation to match every negative entry could make difficult to meet. We therefore introduce a societal fund issuing supplementary, temporary transition quotas. These represent a debt towards future generations: permission to make a gradual adjustment while acknowledging that part of the imbalance remains. The fund creates room for change; the recognition of debt keeps that room from being confused with a completed restoration.

The supplementary supply must decline. Quotas are set annually by country, each year's amount strictly lower than the previous year's. They also have expiry dates intended to discourage prolonged accumulation and speculation. The objective is an economy maintaining the capital it uses without needing these additional transition permissions. Rights arising from genuine positive contributions have a different origin. Distinguishing the two sources allows us to see whether an activity is supported by an actual contribution or by temporary room granted during the transition.

As temporary permissions become scarcer, persistent negative balances should become more costly to carry. Firms would have a reason to improve methods or seek recognised contributions elsewhere. Competition can then reward a lower restoration requirement. The institution need not select every technology in advance. Producers compare alternatives under an altered cost structure, while the societal account establishes which changes really reduce their demand for rights. The response will depend on supply, prices and the quality of the underlying measurement.

Keynes's analysis of liquidity preference shows how money's role reaches into investment. People may keep liquid balances because they face uncertain future needs or expect interest rates to change, and their willingness to part with liquidity affects financing conditions. 4 I apply that attention to monetary arrangements to a different purpose. Expiring transition quotas are intended to discourage indefinite accumulation, while a declining supplementary supply makes persistent negative balances more expensive to carry. The intended incentives concern present production's demands on capacities needed later. Their effectiveness has to be tested through actual responses to the instrument's rules.

Country allocations would shape who bears the adjustment. I favour population, or another indicator connected to living needs, over existing economic output. Otherwise a history of intensive resource use could become a continuing entitlement to more of a shared resource. Countries needing fewer quotas could sell a surplus to those needing more. Choosing the allocation still requires political agreement. The measure can make the distribution explicit; it cannot supply everyone's consent to a particular distribution simply because its quantities are comparable.

The fund's resources should serve universal purposes. Reliable measurement comes first, since the system needs practical means to establish and improve its accounts. The fund could also support shared knowledge or physical greenhouse-gas reduction. Restricting its purpose aims to prevent local allocation struggles from consuming the agreement on which the measure rests. Its spending should be judged against the common capital it is responsible for maintaining, with evidence showing what a financed activity actually contributes.

Purchasing a right still differs from completing a physical repair. Compensation elsewhere can balance an economic obligation while the original pollutant remains. Physical quantities must stay in the records, and a removal claim must be supported by removal evidence. Similarly, describing an instrument as money supplies no automatic rules for lending, redemption or a fixed exchange rate with existing currencies. I set out a tool based on contributions and declining transition quotas; those additional arrangements require separate decisions and tests.

Like a learned Mahalanobis metric used in classification, a measure of shared obligations can support negentropic money as a tool for changing producers’ choices about shared capital.

References

1. Mahalanobis, P. C. (1936). On the generalized distance in statistics. Proceedings of the National Institute of Sciences of India, 2(1), 49–55. https://insa.nic.in/UI/Archivesection.aspx?JID=MA%3D%3D&JYrs=MTkzNg%3D%3D

2. Weinberger, K. Q., & Saul, L. K. (2009). Distance metric learning for large margin nearest neighbor classification. Journal of Machine Learning Research, 10, 207–244. https://jmlr.org/papers/v10/weinberger09a.html

3. Lascols, B. (2026). Capital and entropy: Theory of negentropic value (4th ed.). Accounting for externalities.

4. Keynes, J. M. (1936). The general theory of employment, interest and money. Macmillan. https://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/economics/keynes/general-theory/