A falling weight turns a paddle in water, and the water warms. An electric current heats a conductor. James Prescott Joule compared such effects with extraordinary care, helping establish a common account of energy for mechanical work, electricity and heat. Thermodynamics connected transformations previously studied through separate theories; it did not make every electrical phenomenon a problem in heat. Its achievement was to identify something that could be followed through the differences. A common measure let experimenters ask where the energy had gone. 1
Economics has its own differences to follow. Labour describes the effort involved in production. Utility concerns the usefulness of its result. Nature supplies capacities before anyone starts work, and collective knowledge makes work more effective. The negentropic value brings these contributions into an account of productive potential. The ambition is to include what earlier definitions illuminate while also recognising what an exchange can leave unpaid: the maintenance of the natural and social capital that makes the next exchange possible. 2
Adam Smith helps us begin with cooperation. His account of the division of labour explains how specialisation raises output through acquired dexterity, saved time and improvements in machinery. A worker's productive power depends on an arrangement extending beyond that worker. Smith also distinguished usefulness from exchange value; he never offered a simple rule that everything useful commands a high price. These observations belong together. Economic capability emerges through relationships, while the terms of a sale reveal only a particular judgement about its product. 3
This is an opening into social capital. A shared technical language lets specialists understand one another. Education makes their instructions usable. Reliable institutions allow a supplier to commit resources before receiving payment. These capacities have histories of creation and maintenance, although a customer buying the finished object rarely sees them itemised. The object carries the benefit of cooperation that its maker could not have produced alone. Recognising that inheritance gives a fuller account of where productivity comes from.
David Ricardo brought a different discipline to value. He made utility a necessary condition of exchange value, then distinguished scarce goods from goods whose supply could be expanded through production. For the latter, relative labour requirements were central to his explanation. He also examined complications arising from capital and the time before products reached the market. We lose the argument if we reduce it to the claim that any extra hour spent on anything makes it worth more. Ricardo was trying to explain relative values under specified production conditions. 4
Those conditions matter. Suppose equally skilled workers in two workshops make identical tables. One receives sound timber; the other receives timber requiring treatment. The second workshop needs more effort to deliver the same service. Part of the first workshop's advantage existed before its employees began. Nature had provided material in a favourable condition. Labour transforms an inheritance, and the amount of labour needed depends on what that inheritance already offers.
William Stanley Jevons shifted attention towards the usefulness of an additional quantity. A person already well supplied with a good may value another unit less than someone who lacks it. The judgement depends on circumstances, and exchange concerns the quantities available at the margin. Production costs still enter his analysis through their effects on supply. His account gives no reason to expect that the labour embodied in an unwanted object will compel someone to buy it. 5
I retain that freedom of judgement. A maintenance account cannot decide whether someone prefers a table to a holiday. Nor would measuring productive potential predict every price, which also reflects bargaining conditions, scarcity and purchasing power. The question is what remains after the preference has been satisfied. Did providing the table preserve an equivalent capacity to produce useful things, or did an attractive sale consume a common inheritance without paying for its upkeep?
Negentropy names the usable quantity we should recognize. A material's concentration, an implement's condition and the accessibility of knowledge affect what can be done with them. Their economic importance extends beyond the energy consumed in making them. Information must have meaning for a user; a tool must fit a task. I am proposing a basis for assessing capacities and their maintenance, rather than converting all human preferences into a physical quantity. A financial price and a thermodynamic measurement cannot simply be declared interchangeable.
The connection with labour now becomes clearer. Work may create organisation, preserve it or recover it after use. Natural processes can also supply organisation without paid labour. Utility expresses how an available capacity serves a particular person. A negentropic account places these contributions beside the demands made on the resources supporting them. It widens the question from the effort expended and the satisfaction obtained to the capacity left available afterwards.
Consider a repair manual made freely available by a group of manufacturers. Writing it requires skilled work; its value to a reader depends on accuracy and intelligibility. Each successful repair can preserve equipment without generating another payment to its authors. Updating the manual maintains a shared productive resource. Its contribution is real even where the transaction record is silent. Conversely, a profitable sale of equipment that nobody can repair may create an obligation that the sale price scarcely acknowledges.
Smith's account of specialisation also helps explain why gains can emerge without anyone directing the entire chain. Such gains can be reinterpreted through cooperation and accumulated learning. This is no warrant to assume that every private advantage benefits everyone. A chain can coordinate production efficiently while drawing down resources outside its agreements. Its success has to be assessed at that wider boundary, where the work of maintaining common capacities becomes visible.
A maintenance comparison can also explain why a smaller visible effort is sometimes a greater achievement. If a better design preserves the same service with fewer inputs, its contribution includes the resources spared. Counting hours alone would miss that improvement, while the sale alone might miss who receives its wider benefit. The account follows the capability preserved.
The inclusion is therefore practical. Labour remains a contribution, usefulness remains a judgement, and exchange remains a means of coordination. The additional account asks what these activities inherit and what they leave behind. It must preserve evidence about the resources being compared, so a change in a conversion rule cannot masquerade as a real improvement. A common measure earns its place by helping us distinguish productive achievement from an unpaid loss of productive capacity.
Joule followed energy through mechanical work, electrical heating and heat, and I seek a comparable continuity among accounts of value by following the productive potential that labour, nature and useful cooperation provide.
References
1. Joule, J. P. (1850). On the mechanical equivalent of heat. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 140, 61–82. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstl.1850.0004
2. Lascols, B. (2026). Capital and entropy: Theory of negentropic value (4th ed.). Accounting for externalities.
3. Smith, A. (1904). An inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations (E. Cannan, Ed.). Methuen & Co. https://www.econlib.org/library/Smith/smWN.html (Original work published 1776)
4. Ricardo, D. (1821). On the principles of political economy and taxation (3rd ed.). John Murray. https://www.econlib.org/library/Ricardo/ricP.html (Original work published 1817)
5. Jevons, W. S. (1888). The theory of political economy (3rd ed.). Macmillan and Co. https://www.econlib.org/library/YPDBooks/Jevons/jvnPE.html (Original work published 1871)
